Vitalik Buterin: Michael Saylor's Bitcoin Self-Custody Comments Are 'Batshit Insane'

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has openly criticized MicroStrategy co-founder Michael Saylor's recent remarks on Bitcoin self-custody.

During a recent interview, Saylor was asked whether leaving Bitcoin custody to large banks and third-party entities poses a centralization risk, with the potential for government seizure of individuals’ crypto holdings.

The MicroStrategy co-founder responded that when Bitcoin is held by "paranoid crypto-anarchists" who do not acknowledge government regulations, the risk of seizure increases.

Buterin disagreed in a subsequent tweet. "I'll happily say that I think Saylor's comments are batshit insane,” he wrote, adding that Saylor “seems to be explicitly arguing for a regulatory capture approach to protecting crypto." The Ethereum co-founder also added that such an approach does not align with the core principles of cryptocurrency.

What is self-custody?

Self-custody is the process of retaining control over one’s private keysprivate keys, meaning that no outside party has access to your cryptocurrency walletcryptocurrency wallet.

Because this approach involves a degree of inconvenience and risk —keys can be lost or stolen, with no redress—some users instead turn to third-party custody. This involves an independent custodian controlling the private keys to a wallet where the user’s crypto is held.

BTC

+6.19%$102,929.83

---

24H7D1M1YMAX

Price data by

BTC price

The risks associated with third-party custody are often summarized by the saying, "not your keys, not your coins," meaning that the third party has full control over the assets, and could—in theory—either freeze or appropriate them, or be pressured into doing so by the authorities.

The self-custody debate

Buterin was responding to a tweet by Jameson Lopp, cypherpunk and co-founder of Bitcoin self-custody platform Casa HODL, who shared his perspective on self-custody. Lopp emphasized that self-custody is essential not just for individual Bitcoin holders but for the network's overall health. "Self-custody is important for the continued strengthening and improvement of the entire network," he said.

Lopp explained how centralizing coins in a few wallets increases systemic risk of loss and seizure and disenfranchises users from running nodes or trading forks.

Bitcoin Self-Custody Enshrined As a Right In Oklahoma

Oklahoma has become the first U.S. state to pass a law protecting the right to self-custody Bitcoin. The new law says citizens cannot be prevented from holding and controlling digital assets using a hardware wallet. It also says that the state government cannot ban or restrict the use of crypto to purchase legal goods and services. The so-called ‘Bitcoin Rights’ bill—HB3594—was signed into law by Oklahoma’s Republican governor Kevin Stitt Monday, and the non-profit Satoshi Action Fund says more...

He also claimed that it would decrease development incentives since “institutions don't care about more advanced cryptographic features” and “permissionless scaling gets deprioritized because we can just scale via trusted third party.”

While Saylor seemingly disagrees, the movement for crypto self-custody is seemingly seeing renewed impetus ever since the collapse of the FTX crypto exchange in 2022. Back in May, Oklahoma became the first U.S. state to pass a law protecting the right to self-custody Bitcoin.

MicroStrategy Aims to Be ‘Bitcoin Bank’ With Trillion-Dollar Valuation: Michael Saylor

MicroStrategy Inc. is positioning itself to transform how capital is preserved and transferred globally, according to a recent report by Bernstein Research—and the company’s outspoken co-founder Michael Saylor says the company aims to become a “Bitcoin bank” with a potential trillion-dollar valuation. Bernstein has rated MicroStrategy as "Outperform," with a price target of $290, reflecting a 39% upside from its current price of $209, according to Google Finance. The report states that MicroStra...

As executive chair of MicroStrategy, Saylor has pursued an aggressive strategy of acquiring Bitcoin for the company’s treasury. The company now holds over 1% of the Bitcoin that will ever be mined, with a dollar value of around $16 billion.

Earlier this month, Saylor outlined MicroStrategy’s plan to shift from being a software company to what he called a "Bitcoin bank" with a potential trillion-dollar valuation, by issuing securities backed by Bitcoin.